Kitchen cabinet renovation: reface, repaint or replace?
Quick answer: Look at the boxes first, not the doors. If the cabinet boxes are sound and the layout works, repainting or refacing keeps the best part of your Melbourne kitchen and skips the demolition. If the boxes are swollen or sagging, or the layout is wrong, new doors will not fix it and replacing is the honest answer. Every option is priced after a site visit, and a full kitchen with new cabinetry runs $25,000 to $55,000 as a gutted. fixed price.
Start with the boxes, not the doors
Most people judge a kitchen by its doors. The doors are the skin. The boxes behind them hold the weight, the plumbing and the appliances, and they decide which of the three options you actually have.
Open every cupboard and drawer and check five things before you ask anyone for a quote.
Swelling or lifting at the base
Water damage shows at the bottom of the sink cabinet and under the dishwasher first. Swollen, crumbling or lifting board does not take a new finish. It takes replacement.
Sag and movement
Shelves bowing, rails pulling away or boxes that have shifted off the wall mean the structure has moved. Doors will not hang straight on a box that is out of square.
Peeling or lifting edges
On laminate and melamine, edges that peel back let water in. A new finish over a failing edge fails with it.
Drawers and hardware
Runners and hinges can often be replaced. Drawer boxes that are broken, swollen or loose cannot be saved by new fronts.
Smell and mould
A damp or musty smell inside a cabinet is a leak you have not found yet. Find it before you spend anything on the finish.
If all five are clean, the boxes are sound and you have three real options. If two or more are not, skip to the section on layout and replacing.
Repaint, reface or replace: what each one fixes and what it cannot
Repaint
A new finish on the doors, drawer fronts and visible boxes you already have. It fixes worn or dated colour and nothing else. It cannot fix damaged boards, a door style you dislike, tired hardware or a layout that does not work. Preparation decides how long it lasts, because these surfaces are handled every day.
Reface
New doors and drawer fronts, and usually new panel ends and edges, fitted to the boxes you keep. It changes the style as well as the colour. It cannot fix the boxes, change the layout or change the size of any opening, so appliances stay where they are.
Replace
New boxes, doors, drawers and hardware. It is the only option that changes the layout, the storage and the appliance sizes. It is also the biggest job, because the old cabinets and usually the benchtop come out. A full kitchen with new cabinetry is $25,000 to $55,000 as a gutted. fixed price.
The honest order is repaint, then reface, then replace. Stop at the first one that solves the problem you actually have.
Layout, appliances and storage: the reasons to replace
Refacing and repainting keep every opening exactly where it is. That is their advantage and their limit.
Replace the cabinets if you want to move the sink, the cooktop or the fridge, fit a bigger or smaller appliance, or put drawers where there are cupboards. If the layout is what is wrong with your kitchen, new doors leave you with the same kitchen and a new face. Moving plumbing, gas or power adds trades and time, so ask for any layout change as its own line. Our kitchen renovation cost guide covers what a full kitchen costs and what drives the price.
The benchtop matters too. Replacing only the doors and drawer fronts leaves it where it is. Replacing the boxes usually means lifting it, and a stone benchtop often cannot be lifted and refitted in one piece. Decide the benchtop before you decide the cabinets.
Older home? Check this first
Homes built or renovated before 1990 are likely to contain asbestos. Victorian guidance for homeowners says not to drill, sand or cut materials that may contain it. Wall sheeting and splashbacks behind old cabinets are places it can be found.
Get a professional assessment, or assume it is present and take precautions. In most cases the law requires a licensed removalist to remove it. A registered builder should ask the age of your home before anything is cut. The Victorian Asbestos Hub explains what to do.
What your doors are made of decides what is possible
Two kitchens that look the same can have very different doors, and the material decides whether a repaint will hold. Check which you have before you choose.
Painted board
Doors made of board with a painted finish can be repainted or refinished if the paint is sound. The edges swell if water gets in, and swollen edges cannot be painted over.
Laminate or melamine
A hard-wearing surface that can be painted only with the right preparation and primer. If the edges are peeling, painting is the wrong fix.
Vinyl-wrapped doors, often called thermofoil
A film wrapped over board. Near an oven or a dishwasher the film can lift and peel, and it cannot be repainted with confidence. New doors are the usual answer.
Timber or veneer
Can be sanded and refinished if the veneer is thick enough and the boxes are sound. A site visit is the only way to tell.
Hardware and details: small parts that decide how it feels
Hinges, runners and handles decide how a kitchen feels every day. They are cheap to get right and annoying to get wrong, and they are the lines most quotes skip.
- Soft-close hinges and runners can usually be fitted to boxes that are sound, and they change how the kitchen feels more than the colour does.
- New handles in new positions mean filling the old holes. That is easy with new doors and fiddly with old ones, so ask who makes good the holes.
- A flat door is the easiest to keep clean. A door with a raised edge collects grease and dust in the grooves.
- Panel ends, kickboards and the gap above the top cupboards are often forgotten. They show the join between old and new if nobody prices them.
Living through the work
Repainting and refacing are usually quicker than replacing, but made-to-measure doors have lead times, and a kitchen without doors or drawer fronts is hard to use. Ask which days you will have no water, no power or no usable storage, and ask for those days in the written timeline.
Replacing takes the kitchen out of action for longer, so plan a temporary set-up before the work starts: a kettle, a bench-top cooker and a tub for dishes in another room is the usual answer. A tidy site at the end of each day matters more when you are living in the house.
What a good quote lists, whichever option you pick
The three options get quoted very differently, and a quote that just says cabinet refresh tells you nothing. Look for these lines:
- Exactly which parts are being repainted, refaced or replaced: doors, drawer fronts, panel ends, kickboards and shelves
- The finish or material, and whether the work is done on site or off site
- Hinges, runners and handles: kept or replaced, and to what standard
- How doors and fronts are measured, and the lead time on made-to-measure parts
- What happens if a box is found damaged once the doors come off
- Protection for floors, walls and the rest of the house, and a tidy site each day
- A written start date and a written end date
For the full list of what belongs in any renovation quote, read what should be in a renovation quote.
Why we say look at the boxes first
A renovator should not recommend a bigger job than you need. A full kitchen at $25,000 to $55,000 is the right answer for a bad layout and the wrong answer for a tired colour.
If repainting or refacing solves your problem, it is the better spend, and we say so at the site visit. If it will not, we say that too, before you have paid for doors that sit on boxes that are failing.
Worth knowing
If your boxes are sound, the layout works and all you want is a new colour, you do not need a renovator. A specialist cabinet painter will do it for less than a renovation, and we will tell you so at the site visit.
If you are well outside 30 km of the Melbourne CBD, a builder closer to you will be easier to reach. And we do not price from photos: every quote follows a site visit.
Get the work and the price in writing
Whatever you choose, put the scope and the price on paper. Work worth more than $10,000 needs a builder registered with the Building and Plumbing Commission (BPC) and a written major domestic building contract, and you can check any builder on the BPC register. For smaller jobs, Consumer Affairs Victoria still recommends a written contract that says exactly what is done and for how much. Our guide on how to choose a kitchen renovation company has the full checklist.
Common questions
Is it cheaper to reface, repaint or replace kitchen cabinets?
Repainting and refacing both cost less than replacing, because they keep the cabinet boxes and skip demolition. They only pay off if the boxes are sound and the layout works. If either is wrong, new doors on bad boxes is money spent on the wrong thing. Every option is priced after a site visit. A full kitchen with new cabinetry is $25,000 to $55,000 as a gutted. fixed price.
What is the difference between refacing and repainting kitchen cabinets?
Repainting changes the finish on the doors and boxes you already have. Refacing replaces the doors and drawer fronts, and usually the visible panel ends and edges, and leaves the boxes in place. Refacing changes the style of the doors. Painting does not.
How do I know if my kitchen cabinets can be refaced?
The boxes have to be sound: dry, square and firmly fixed, with no swelling at the base, no sag in the shelves and no peeling edges. The layout and the appliance sizes also have to suit you, because refacing cannot change either.
When should I replace kitchen cabinets instead of refacing them?
Replace when the boxes are water-damaged or failing, when the layout is wrong, when you are changing appliances or storage, or when you are moving the sink or cooktop. At that point the cabinets are part of a kitchen renovation, and a fixed-price quote should cover the whole job.
Can I paint my kitchen cabinets myself?
Yes, if the boxes are sound. Preparation and the right paint decide how long a finish lasts on doors that are handled every day, so a poor job shows quickly. If your home was built before 1990, do not drill, sand or cut wall sheeting or splashbacks near the cabinets until they have been checked for asbestos.
Can I keep my benchtop if I replace the cabinets?
Sometimes. A stone benchtop often cannot be lifted and refitted in one piece, so replacing the boxes usually means replacing the benchtop too. Replacing only the doors and drawer fronts leaves the benchtop where it is.
How long does it take to reface or replace kitchen cabinets?
Refacing and repainting are usually quicker and less disruptive than replacing, which puts the kitchen out of action for part of the job. Doors and fronts made to measure have a lead time, so ask for a written start date and a written end date before you pay anything.
Do I need a registered builder to renovate kitchen cabinets?
If the work is worth more than $10,000, yes: a builder registered with the Building and Plumbing Commission and a written major domestic building contract. Below that, Consumer Affairs Victoria still recommends a written contract that says exactly what work is done and the total price.
Planning more than the cabinets? Read budget kitchen renovation in Melbourne, small kitchen renovation ideas and how long a kitchen renovation takes. See finished work on our work page.
